Comment Portability: The Commenting Standard of the Future

July 6, 2008

. Tags: blog, Blogging, conversation, disqus, friendfeed, intense debate, sezwho, shyftr, Social Media.

Disqus, IntenseDebate, and SezWho. 3 commenting systems that currently don’t work together, but here’s how they could.

I think it’s possible for the services to come together and develop a standard for commenting systems (as suggested by Dave Stanley of Shyftr). This standard would provide a framework for updating comments across the blog, commenting systems, and third-party services (like FriendFeed or Shyftr).

Of course this also requires input and cooperation from these third-party services for this to really work. The ultimate goal: distributed conversations with aggregated discussions.

What future implications do you think this will have on how you blog and participate in discussions?

Tags: blog, Blogging, conversation, disqus, friendfeed, intense debate, sezwho, shyftr, Social Media

On FriendFeed, this post was liked by 9 people and commented on 4 times hide

View this post on FriendFeed

Liked by

July 6, 2008 at 11:12 pm "Czar" DJ Peterman

Good idea, having three different commenting profiles is just ridiculous. On the other hand it keeps certain companies from owning all the comments on the internet...
July 7, 2008 at 12:34 am Shey

I think each service has its strengths, but yes there are a lot of similar features.
July 7, 2008 at 12:42 am Erhan Erdogan

Shey: that s a brilliant image ; )
July 7, 2008 at 1:21 am Shey

Thanks Erhan :)

Viewing 22 Comments

Corvida 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

I don't think services want to do this. They're all competitors. Why would they link up with one another?

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

49 /people/Corvida/ /people/Corvida/following/ http://shegeeks.net in/corvida shegeeks

Shey 2 months ago 2 points
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

I think it's in the best interest for all of the 3 commenting systems:

1) Makes them more attractive to blogs
2) Opens the door for other third-party services to use them as well

Yes, in a sense they are all competitors, but they all have their individual strengths. This will give them a chance to really dive into their niches by investing in the industry as a whole.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

40 /people/shey/ /people/shey/following/ http://www.sheysmith.com in/sweetsopdesign shey sweetsop sweetsop shey

Corvida 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

On an entirely different note, I tried to give your reply a point and for some reason I can't.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

49 /people/Corvida/ /people/Corvida/following/ http://shegeeks.net in/corvida shegeeks

Shey 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

I don't think Disqus allows you to give points to replies. Replies to your own comment that is

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

40 /people/shey/ /people/shey/following/ http://www.sheysmith.com in/sweetsopdesign shey sweetsop sweetsop shey

Michael Koenig 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Shey, Corvida - I hope you don't mind me jumping in here. This is one of our goals at IntenseDebate. We get that having your content spread across a ton of different services is a pain. It would be awesome if all of your content was in one place regardless of which service you use to post it. This topic is definitely on our minds.

This is one of the goals of our FriendFeed integration. We're striving to give you the tools to aggregate your content in cooperation with other 3rd party services so that you're comments are available regardless of which service you use to post it. Whether this is something that we do in-house or something that we work on with our good friends over at Gnip (http://gnnipcentral.com) is still getting hashed out. BTW - check out GNIP. They just launched last week and we're extremely excited about our partnership with our good buddies down the street from us. Keep an eye on them...they're going to change everything.

It should be pretty exciting to see the future of content aggregation. We'll get there!

Cheers,
Michael Koenig
IntenseDebate

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

2 /people/mkoenig/ /people/mkoenig/following/ http://intensedebate.com mkoenig

Shey 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Don't mind at all Michael, thanks for your input.

Just to correct your URL: http://www.gnipcentral.com/

Keep up the great work :)

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

40 /people/shey/ /people/shey/following/ http://www.sheysmith.com in/sweetsopdesign shey sweetsop sweetsop shey

Michael Koenig 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Thanks Shey (and thanks for correcting my link...fat finger slip, these things happen).

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

2 /people/mkoenig/ /people/mkoenig/following/ http://intensedebate.com mkoenig

Shey 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

On an unrelated note, I'm now getting emails from ID whenever someone posts an FF comment on my blog . How do I disable that just for the FF comments?

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

40 /people/shey/ /people/shey/following/ http://www.sheysmith.com in/sweetsopdesign shey sweetsop sweetsop shey

Michael Koenig 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Thanks for letting me know Shey. In your IntenseDebate profile (http://intensedebate.com/editprofile) have you selected the "Pull in comments made on my blog posts in FriendFeed" check box?

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

2 /people/mkoenig/ /people/mkoenig/following/ http://intensedebate.com mkoenig

Shey 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

No, it's not selected.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

40 /people/shey/ /people/shey/following/ http://www.sheysmith.com in/sweetsopdesign shey sweetsop sweetsop shey

Michael Koenig 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Ok. thanks Shey. I'll get to the bottom of this. I'll keep you posted.

Sorry about taking over your comment section here. I'm more than willing to keep the conversation going here (especially to keep anyone interested in the loop, since it pertains to comment portability), but I'd completely understand if you'd prefer to move this conversation from your blog to email in order to spare your readers. Please let me know and feel free to email.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

2 /people/mkoenig/ /people/mkoenig/following/ http://intensedebate.com mkoenig

Michael Koenig 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

An update for anyone interested: we've identified why Shey was receiving these email notifications and have corrected the issue.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

2 /people/mkoenig/ /people/mkoenig/following/ http://intensedebate.com mkoenig

robdiana 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

actually, there has been talk of getting a standard for comments together by the various sites. It is not entirely formalized yet, but hopefully it can get off the ground.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

4 /people/robdiana/ /people/robdiana/following/ http://regulargeek.com/

svartling 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Great idea.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

6 /people/svartling/ /people/svartling/following/ http://www.svartling.net/ svartling svartling svartling svartling

Yuvi Panda 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

They should.

Hope they will.

Good Call.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

6 /people/yuvipanda/ /people/yuvipanda/following/ http://blog.yuvisense.net yuvipanda yuvipanda

calebelston 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

We can only hope we see something like this soon. hComment

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

18 /people/calebelston/ /people/calebelston/following/ http://www.toluu.com/betainvite calebelston

Shey 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Thanks Caleb,

Any plans to add any kind of commenting to Toluu or would that overcomplicate the service?

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

40 /people/shey/ /people/shey/following/ http://www.sheysmith.com in/sweetsopdesign shey sweetsop sweetsop shey

calebelston 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

Not in our current plans, but things can always change. We always think about adding features that will give the most value to the most users. At some point comments about a blog may be helpful in deciding if a blog is worth your time.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

18 /people/calebelston/ /people/calebelston/following/ http://www.toluu.com/betainvite calebelston

nikan 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

I had a similar idea when I heard of identi.ca: we can use federated microblogging as blog commenting system. That would bring the conversation back to the blogs and enrich them with the microblogging communities. All these, provided there is a standard for microblogging services to talk to each other, understand trackbacks etc.
In any case, I am a proponent of the idea of unified commenting.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

3 /people/nikan/ /people/nikan/following/ http://metablogging.gr nikan metablogging chartopontikas

vrypan 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

It should be as easy as adding a trackback URL to the comment field (or even, trying to trackback the "homepage" URL most comment forms already have).

This way, any post I leave anywhere will be also posted back to my own, personal, "comment tracking system", or even integrated in my blog, as posts. Open, simple, portable and most parts are already implemented in various programming languages.

reply edit reblog flag record video comment

3 /people/vrypan/ /people/vrypan/following/ http://vrypan.net/

WillBrown 2 months ago 1 point
Please login to rate.

Add New Comment on FriendFeed

Add New Comment

Viewing 22 Comments

Comment Portability: The Commenting Standard of the Future

Related posts

Add New Comment on FriendFeed

Add New Comment

Viewing 22 Comments